Remote leadership in the Middle East: Balancing tradition with modernity in a New Work Era

Gepubliceerd
16 oktober 2024
Read
8 minutes
Remote leadership in the Middle East: Balancing tradition with modernity in a New Work Era
The rise of remote and hybrid work models has redefined the way business is conducted globally, and the Middle East is no exception. Traditionally, the region has prioritized in-person interactions and a relationship-driven approach to business. However, the COVID-19 pandemic and global digital transformation have accelerated the adoption of remote leadership, challenging long-standing norms and reshaping the corporate landscape.

To better understand how these changes are impacting the region, Aspire HR Consultants together with Kestria UAE conducted a survey among decision-makers and employees, yielding insights into the current state of remote leadership and the evolving dynamics of the modern workplace.

The survey findings highlight the unique challenges and adaptations shaping the future of work in the Middle East, providing a comprehensive view of how leadership and employee perspectives differ and where they align. 

A paradigm shift in Middle Eastern leadership

The COVID-19 pandemic acted as a catalyst for change in the Middle East, forcing companies to rapidly adopt remote work models to maintain business continuity. This shift has prompted leaders to rethink how they manage teams, build relationships and maintain productivity in a virtual environment. The survey gathered insights from 368 participants including key decision-makers and employees. Among the decision-makers, 24.73% were employers, 30.98% were line managers and 17.93% were HR leads. Meanwhile, 26.36% of the participants were employees. This mix of perspectives provides a unique view of the opportunities and challenges involved in this transition.

Geographic Scope: The survey featured a diverse mix of respondents from across the Middle East, with significant representation from Egypt, Saudi Arabia, the UAE and Jordan, alongside a few voices from Bahrain, Kuwait and Qatar. The data provides a well-rounded view of the remote work experience in the Middle East.

Please note that in many cases, percentages do not total 100 due to the allowance of multiple selections in the survey.

Interesting findings

The survey results provide insights into the types of work arrangements and benefits currently in place across various organisations. In terms of work arrangements, a hybrid setup, which involves a mix of remote and in-office work, is the most common with 44.39% of organisations implementing this approach. Fully in-office arrangements are a close second, adopted by 41.95%. Flexible arrangements, where employees have the autonomy to choose their schedules, are in place at 11.71%. Meanwhile, 6.83% operate fully remotely and 3.41% reported using other types of work setups.

When it comes to benefits offered, flexible working hours top the list, provided by 54.15% of organisations. Work-from-home options are also popular, available in 50.73%. Mentoring programs are offered to 22.93% of respondents, while 15.12% offer mental counseling services. Furthermore, unpaid sabbaticals are available in 12.68% of employer respondents, and 8.78% provide paid time off for volunteering. Furthermore, 22.93% indicated that they offer other benefits not specified in the list.

The comparison between the type of work arrangements currently in place and those preferred by employees highlights interesting insights. Currently, 44.39% of organisations have adopted a hybrid model (mix of remote and in-office), whereas a significantly higher percentage, 65.85%, believe that the hybrid arrangement is the most preferred by their employees. Similarly, while only 11,71% of organisations offer a flexible model where employees can choose their own schedules, 29.27% of respondents perceive this arrangement as a preferred option for employees. Conversely, 41.95% of organisations have a fully in-office setup, but only 9.27% consider it to be favored by employees.

The rise of remote leadership: Drivers and impacts

The shift to remote work has been driven by two main factors: the necessity to adapt to health and safety concerns during the pandemic and the acceleration of digital transformation. While some organisations have made the transition smoothly, many have faced significant challenges, particularly around maintaining effective leadership in a remote context.

  • COVID-19 as a Catalyst: The pandemic forced around 60% of the surveyed organisations in the region to continue adopting some form of remote work, a stark contrast to pre-pandemic norms, where less than 15% had flexible work policies in place.
  • Digital Transformation: Almost all organisations who adopted some sort of remote work had to accelerate their digital transformation efforts to accommodate remote work, investing in communication tools and cloud-based solutions.

Employer perspective: Benefits of the New Work arrangements

A significant 44.39% of employers surveyed reported utilizing a hybrid work model, combining both on-site and remote work. The shift to hybrid work has brought numerous advantages for both employees and organisations. 53.17% of employers observed better work-life balance for their teams, while 51.22% noted improved employee well-being. Financially, 35.12% reported cost savings on office space and 26.83% saw increased productivity among their workforce. Additionally, 18.54% experienced a reduction in employee turnover and 12.68% found that hybrid arrangements offered access to a wider talent pool. These benefits highlight why hybrid models are becoming a cornerstone of modern workplace strategies, blending flexibility and efficiency to create a more sustainable and attractive work environment.

Employee perspective: Benefits of the New Work arrangements

From the employee standpoint, the new work arrangements have brought a variety of benefits. A significant 59.04% of employees surveyed reported an improvement in work-life balance as the most commonly cited advantage. This was followed by a significant reduction in commute time, experienced by 49.40% of respondents. Flexibility in work hours was another key benefit, highlighted by 42.77%.

Additionally, 31.93% of employees felt that their well-being and mental health had improved, while 30.72% noted an increase in productivity. Furthermore, 16.27% mentioned having more control over their work environment, which may contribute to greater job satisfaction. A small percentage 13.25% indicated other unique benefits specific to their roles and circumstances. These findings underline the value of hybrid and flexible work models in enhancing the overall employee experience.

The challenges of remote leadership: Decision Makers’ perspectives

The adoption of remote leadership has been a mixed experience for decision-makers. While they recognize the potential benefits of flexible work models, they have also faced a range of unique challenges that are reshaping leadership practices in the region.

1. Maintaining communication and collaboration

  • Around 44% of Line Managers cited communication as a top challenge, with many struggling to ensure that information flows effectively in remote teams. They noted that the lack of informal office interactions makes it difficult to maintain team cohesion.
  • More than 35% of Employers reported reduced team cohesion and difficulty in maintaining company culture.

2. Trust and accountability

  • Trust emerged as a critical issue with more than 70% of Employers & line managers indicating that they are still not confident in their ability to monitor productivity and ensure accountability remotely. Only 23% are using tools to measure the productivity of employees in remote or hybrid work arrangements.
  • When a random sample of line managers was personally interviewed, all reported that their primary concern is ensuring that team members are engaged and not experiencing “digital presenteeism” where employees appear online but are not actively contributing

3. Cultural adaptation and hierarchy

  • All interviewed sample of decision-makers agreed that traditional leadership practices, which emphasize hierarchy and visibility, need to be redefined to suit a remote context.

4. Digital infrastructure and readiness

  • While urban centers are well-equipped, rural areas in certain countries cited poor connectivity as a major barrier to effective remote leadership.
  • 21% of HR Leads & 30% of employees believe that a lack of digital tools across departments, including the Internet and other tools, are important challenge in remote work experiences leading to friction and reduced productivity.

Employee challenges: Reality on the ground

Employees, while generally supportive of remote and hybrid models, face a distinct set of challenges that impact their productivity and well-being. The survey results reveal key areas of concern:

1. Difficulty separating work and home life

  • 37.95% of employees reported struggling to maintain boundaries between personal and professional life, a figure that is even higher among those living in extended family households, a common living arrangement in the region.

2. Communication barriers and feeling isolated

  • 34.34% cited communication barriers as a major challenge, with 26.51% mentioning feelings of isolation or disconnection from their teams.
  • Younger employees (ages 20-35) were 45% more likely to report feeling isolated compared to older employees, reflecting the importance of social interactions for younger workers.

3. Technical issues

  • 29.52% experienced technical issues such as unreliable internet or insufficient digital tools, which hindered their ability to work effectively.

4. Mental Health and Well-Being

  • 63.26%% of employees reported that their mental health had “improved significantly” or they have noticed ‘some improvement ‘due to the flexibility offered by hybrid work.
  • However, 30.72.% indicated no change and 6.03% experienced a decline in mental health, suggesting that while remote work has benefits, it does not equally serve all employees.

Key adaptations by Middle Eastern executives

Given these challenges, decision-makers have started to implement several key adaptations to support their teams: 

1. Structured Hybrid Models

  • More than 40% of surveyed organisations have adopted structured hybrid models, where employees spend 1-4 days remotely and the remaining days working from office. This model allows for a balance between collaboration and focused work.

2. Enhanced Digital Tools

  • When a random sample of decision-makers was interviewed, almost all companies reported that they have invested in new digital tools such as Microsoft Teams, Zoom, and Slack to facilitate better communication and project management. They also mentioned that at least 50% of line managers have received training on how to lead effectively in a virtual setting.

3. Empathy and Emotional Intelligence

  • 100% of HR Leads interviewed are prioritising empathy and emotional intelligence in leadership development programs, recognising that these skills are crucial for managing remote teams.

The role of Executive Search firms in identifying Remote-Ready leaders

Executive search firms are evolving their strategies to identify leaders who can thrive in remote or hybrid environments. The emphasis is now on:

1. Agility and adaptability

  • Executive search firms are increasingly prioritizing candidates who demonstrate agility in managing remote teams and navigating uncertainty.

2. Digital literacy

  • Strong proficiency in using digital tools and platforms is now considered a core competency, with the majority of recruiters including it as a top criterion in leadership assessments.

3. Communication skills

Long-term implications for the Middle East

The future of remote work in the Middle East is hybrid, but success will depend on how well organisations can bridge the gap between leadership strategies and employee needs. By prioritizing flexibility, empathy and effective communication, leaders can create a thriving remote culture that meets the needs of both leadership and employees.

Will Hybrid Become the New Normal? Around 50% of decision-makers respondents believe that hybrid work will continue, & 34% are not sure yet. As for Employees’ respondents around 70% are currently working fully remote or hybrid and  80% of them are either satisfied or very satisfied with this work arrangements. This indicates that hybrid work is here to stay but the specifics of implementation will need to be tailored to the unique cultural and logistical context of the Middle East.

A New Era of leadership in the Middle East

The survey results reflect a promising yet challenging shift toward remote and hybrid work in the Middle East. While decision-makers and employees generally agree on the value of flexibility, their experiences and expectations reveal a gap that must be addressed. To succeed in this evolving environment, leaders need to prioritize empathy, adaptability and digital literacy. As organisations refine their strategies, those that effectively balance traditional values with modern management practices will be best positioned to thrive in the new era of work.

Founder & Managing Director
Rania Abdalla
Wij waarderen uw privacy

Door "Alles accepteren" te selecteren, geeft u toestemming voor ons gebruik van cookies. Meer leren